The FDA quilt has a whole lot of holes in it….

Okay, I’m frustrated.

A few weeks ago I went to the Fancy Foods Festival in NYC. There were literally thousands of booths there. Companies came from all over the world. I was well aware that this was not a gluten free event but that there would be many gluten free companies present. Always excited to learn about new products, I practically sprinted across the expo, quickly nixing booths that displayed bread on their tables and other red flags. I sought out booths that had a gluten free label/certification displayed or had foods that should be naturally gluten free. At every booth I approached I asked if their foods were gluten free and (very specifically) if they were made in a dedicated gluten free facility.

I took home dozens of business cards from companies that were interested in being featured on my blog. I emailed about twenty of these companies to confirm their gluten free status/dedicated facility, and you know what? I threw half of those cards away. The conversation would go something like this:

Me: I was told that your products are gluten free and made in a dedicated facility. Could you confirm this?

Company A: YES WE ARE GLUTEN FREE!!!

Me: Great, do you have a dedicated facility? GF certification? How many ppm do you test to?

Company A: We don’t test, no certification, gluten-containing products are made on the same equipment. BUT WE ARE GLUTEN FREE!!!

Or

Company B: YES! All of our products except one are gluten free. That one is made in a separate facility to prevent cross contamination.

Me: Great! So that means that your gluten free products are made in a dedicated gluten free facility?

Company B: Actually, none of our products are gluten free….

Or

Company C: We are gluten free! Our facility and co-packer can’t make any cross contamination guarantees, but they clean, so all is good.

Or

Company D: Shared equipment, shared facility, no certification, but we test our final product for gluten once a year!

(This company got annoyed with me when I said I didn’t want to review their products – “But we meet the FDA standard!!”)

And some of these companies actually advertise their products as gluten free on their label! That is the problem with the FDA ruling. Companies are not required to test their products for gluten or have dedicated facilities/production lines. But if their products happen to be tested, they must test under 20ppm.

And those disclaimers that say if a product is made in a facility/on equipment that also processes nuts, milk, soy, wheat, ect? – That is a voluntary label. Companies are not required to list any of that information. In fact, I’ve come across a company that shares their gluten free line with wheat-based pretzels – they exclude wheat in that voluntary statement yet list the other allergens that are present. What???

There needs to be better standards for gluten free products. Today, gluten free does not always mean Celiac safe, though it should. (And don’t even get me started on restaurants – “Our fries are gluten free but made in the same fryer as breaded items”…great….) There are so many holes in the FDA legislation. We deserve better. But until that happens, we need to know how to protect ourselves.

So my advice to you – when you see a gluten free label without an official certification stamp, do not take it for face value. Call or email the company. Ask if they have dedicated facilities/equipment, if they test for gluten, what they do to prevent cross contamination. Use your judgment. If it doesn’t meet your standards or something feels fishy, move on to a brand that you can trust.

Stay safe, my friends.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “The FDA quilt has a whole lot of holes in it….

  1. Even a certification stamp is no guarantee the product is made on dedicated equipment or in a dedicated facility. More and more, I am seeing voluntary shared equipment statements on products that also carry a certification seal. There needs to be a higher level of certification for those who are serious about it!

    I was in a dedicated gluten-free bakery recently that is certified by an outside agency. I asked what the testing requirements are. For them, it was one test a week, done in house. Not a test sent to a lab and not a test of each product. One cross-contaminated batch of flour could come and go from their bakery without ever being caught by their once a week test.

    No idea how to fix this but agree with your post. Very well said!

    Like

    • All good points! And yes, I was shocked the first time that I saw a “made on shared equipment” disclaimer on a product that had a GF certification (I was/am not thrilled about this). I generally feel very uncomfortable about products made on shared equipment, even if there is a certification involved. I will ask a certified company a whole lot of questions, and only if I’m personally satisfied with their cleaning practices will I eat/recommend that product.

      And let’s not forget that Cheerios are certified and had that awful recall. Also, there are no regulations concerning purity protocol oats vs. mechanically sorted oats when it comes to a certification.

      I agree that there need to be better standards across the board.

      I often chat with companies who have naturally gluten free products. All ingredients are gluten free, dedicated facility/equipment, and very good practices to ensure that no gluten comes into contact with their products. Perhaps they do not test or have a certification because it is too expensive for their small business. But I often feel comfortable with companies such as these.

      There are so many factors involved in all of this, so for now we must rely on using our best judgement.

      Like

  2. Pingback: Celiac Awareness Month with Tasty Meditation | tasty meditation

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s